Orange Village Planning & Zoning Commission
Architectural Board of Review
Tuesday, July 19, 2011 – 7:30 pm
|
|
MINUTES
Mayor Mulcahy called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm.
Members Present: Anthony Lazar (arrived 7:33 pm), Jud Kline, Scott Lewis, Herb Braverman,
Brian Hitt, Mayor Kathy Mulcahy
Members Absent: None
Others Present: Rebecca Schaltenbrand, Asst. Law Director
Ron Kluchin, Village Architect
Lou Hovancsek, Building Commissioner
Mary Fisco, PZ/ABR Secretary
#1 DECK - Jonathan Fanaroff, Owner
- 715 Beacon Hill Dr.
- Custom Decks
Present: Gene Klonowski - Gene Klonowski, Representative
PZ/ABR Discussion: Joint motion to approve was made by Hitt; seconded by Lewis.
Ayes: Lazar, Kline, Lewis, Braverman, Hitt, Mulcahy
No: None
#2 FENCE - Jonathan Spurlock, Owner
- 30099 Miles Rd.
- Best Fence
- Matt McMahon, Representative
Present: Matt McMahon
PZ/ABR Discussion: Joint motion to approve was made by Lewis; seconded by Braverman.
Ayes: Lazar, Kline, Lewis, Braverman, Hitt, Mulcahy
No: None
#3 FENCE - Scott & Kim Joseph, Owner & Representative
- 300 Capitol Hill Circle
- Henry Fence
- Rodney Simon, Representative
Present: Rodney Simon, Scott Joseph, Ken Jaryga (Neighbor)
PZ/ABR Discussion: Mr. Simon advised the Commission that the fence will be constructed
on property owned by the Josephs’. The proponents, in order to address concerns regarding
the property line, will have a new survey done. The proponents agreed to call the Building
Commissioner with the date that the survey will be conducted in order that the Building Commission
may notify the Jaryga’s when this is scheduled should they want to be present. The gate in the rear
of the property will not be included. The Building Department will review the new drawing.
Motion to approve was made by Lazar; seconded by Kline.
Ayes: Lazar, Kline, Lewis, Braverman, Hitt, Mulcahy
No: None
#4 DECK - David Moorhead, Owner & Contractor
- 29799 Jackson Rd.
Present: Eli Mahler - Eli Mahler, Architect & Representative
PZ/ABR Discussion: Joint motion to approve subject to using 5 quarter, pressure treated wood was
made by Hitt; seconded by Kline.
Ayes: Lazar, Kline, Lewis, Braverman, Hitt, Mulcahy
No: None
#5 ADDITION - Vladimir & Olga Khramoy, Owner
- 4000 West Ash Ln.
- Mikhail Sudnitsyn, Architect, Representative
Present: Mikhail Sudnitsyn
PZ/ABR Discussion: Motion to approve subject to the new materials to match the existing materials
was made by Hitt; seconded by Braverman.
Ayes: Lazar, Kline, Lewis, Braverman, Hitt, Mulcahy
No: None
#6 SIGN - Lakeshore Learning Store
- 27450 Chagrin Blvd.
- Christina Petric, Representative
Present: Christina Petric, Rob Risman (Orange Plaza)
PZ/ABR Discussion: Motion to approve was made by Lazar; seconded by Kline.
Ayes: Lazar, Kline, Lewis, Braverman, Hitt, Mulcahy
No: None
#7 REPORT & RECOMMENDATION, (Ordinance 2011-12 As Amended)
An Ordinance granting certain variances for a private garage to Carl Hagerling for his
property located at 4939 Woodcrest Drive.
Present: Carl Hagerling
Mr. Carl Hagerling was sworn in by the Assistant Director of Law. The Commission discussed
the practical difficulty or “hardship” standard of review for the granting of a variance, set forth in
Section 1142.06(b) of the Codified Ordinances, and Mr. Hagerling reminded the Commission
that the variance was requested in order to provide garage parking for a recreational vehicle.
The Commission noted that this variance request is substantially similar to Mr. Hagerling’s
variance request that was reviewed by the Commission and approved by Village Council in
July of 2010. It was noted that this variance request is for two variances and that the third
variance for a front yard setback that was approved in 2010 is no longer needed as the current
plans provide for the construction of a new home and not the remodel of an existing home.
Mr. Hagerling’s variance application indicated that he is “receptive to accepting a deed restriction
on the property” to prevent possible non-residential usage of the garage. The Commission, noting
previous discussions on Mr. Hagerling’s current variance request and 2010 variance request,
recommends the execution of a Declarations of Covenants and Restrictions as a condition of
variance approval.
#7 REPORT & RECOMMENDATION, (Ordinance 2011-12 As Amended) Continued:
The Commission also noted that, if the variance is approved by Village Council, the project
would appear before the Commission and the Architectural Board of Review for review.
PZ Discussion: Motion to recommend was made by Lewis; seconded by Braverman.
Ayes: Lazar, Lewis, Braverman, Mulcahy
No: Hitt
#8 BUILDING COMMISSIONER’S REPORT
· Lou spoke with the Landerwood Glen’s property manager, Howard Danzinger
in regards to when will the newly installed fence along Lander Road be painted.
Howard stated it would be painted in the next week or two.
#9 ARCHITECT REPORT
· Ron Kluchin will work on a ‘criteria list’ for fence submittals. He will also review
this with the Building Commissioner.
Ron has been busy with meetings and pricing in going forward with the amphitheater
and future Service Department facility.
#10 ANY OTHER TOPIC FOR DISCUSSION
It was requested that the Assistant Law Director work with the Architect and Building
Commissioner to draft legislation requiring vinyl coating on wire fences for consideration
and review by the Commission.
Motion to approve the Minutes of the July 5, 2011 meeting was made by Braverman; seconded by
Hitt with the following correction:
On project #2, on bullet #2, remove the word “and”.
Ayes: Lazar, Kline, Lewis, Braverman, Hitt
No: None
Abstain: Mulcahy
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 9:09 pm.
_______________________________________ ________________
Mary Fisco, PZ/ABR Secretary Date
Archives 2005 3-05 | 4-05 | 5-05 | 6-05 | 7-05 | 9-05 | 10-05 | 11-05
Archives 2006 1-06 | 3-06 | 4-4-06 | 4-18-06 | 5-06 | 6-06 | 9-06 | 10-3-06 | 10-17-06 | 11-17-06 | 11-21-06 | 12-12-06
Archives 2007 1-07 | 1-17-07 | 2-6-07 | 2-20-07 | 3-07 | 3-20-07 | 4-3-07 | 4-17-07 | 5-1-07 | 5-15-07 | 6-07 | 6-19-07 | 7-17-07
| 8-7-07 | 8-21-07
9-4-07 | 9-18-07 | 10-2-07 | 10-16-07 | 11-07 | 11-20-07 | 12-04-07 | 12-20-07
Archives 2008 1-15-08 | 2-19-08 | 3-18-08 | 4-1-08 | 4-15-08 |
5-6-08 | 5-20-08 | 6-3-08 |
6-17-08 | 7-1-08 | 7-15-08 | 8-5-08 | 8-19-08 | 9-2-08 | 9-16-08 | 11-18-08
Archives 2009 1-6-09 | 1-20-09 | 2-3-09 | 3-3-09 | 3-17-09 | 4-7-09 | 4-21-09 | 5-19-09| 6-2-09 | 6-19-09
| 7-7-09 | 7-21-09 | 8-18-09 | 9-1-09 | 9-15-09 | 10-6-09 | 10-20-09 | 12-15-09
Archives 2010 1-19-10 | 2-2-10 | 2-16-10 | 3-2-10
| 4-6-10 | 5-4-10
| 6-1-10 | 6-15-10
| 7-6-10 |
8-17-10 |
9-7-10 |
10-5-10 | 10-19-10
| 10-19-10 | 11-16-10 |
12-7-10
Archives 2010 1-18-11 | 2-1-11
| 3-1-11 |
4-5-11 |
4-20-11 |
5-17-11 |
6-7-11 |
6-21-11 |
7-5-11 |