Orange Village Planning & Zoning Commission
Architectural Board of Review
Tuesday, January 2, 2007 – 7:30 pm
|
Orange Village Planning & Zoning Commission Architectural Board of Review Tuesday, January 2, 2007 – 7:30 pm |
|
MINUTES Mayor Mulcahy called for a moment of silence in memory of Barry Byron, former Law Director of Orange Village. Mayor Mulcahy called the meeting to order at 7:30 pm. Members Present: Carmen Centanni, Jonathan Shanes, Brian Hitt, Ed Salim, John Terlep, Jud Kline and Mayor Kathy Mulcahy Others Present: Stephen Byron, Law Director Lou Hovancsek, Building Commissioner Ron Kluchin, Village Architect Nomination of PZ/ABR Chairperson and Chairperson Pro-Tem Discussion was had on why the Mayor should be Chairperson for the PZ/ABR Commission. Jonathan Shanes nominated Carmen Centanni for Chairperson. Brian Hitt nominated Mayor Mulcahy for Chairperson. Discussion was had on why Carmen Centanni should be Chairperson for the PZ/ABR Commission. Vote for Mayor Kathy Mulcahy: Vote for Carmen Centanni: Ayes: Hitt, Salim and Mulcahy Ayes: Centanni and Shanes Vote for Brian Hitt as Chairperson Pro-Tem: Ayes: Centanni, Shanes, Hitt, Salim and Mulcahy No: None #1 ADDITION and REMODEL - Drs. Martin Shill & Eve Echt, Owner - 3980 Beechmont Trail - Bennett/Dover Home Remodelers - Shelley Bujdos & Dave Fry, Representatives Present: Shelley Bujdos and Dave Fry PZ Discussion: Motion to approve contingent upon the Village Engineer’s approval and their Engineer’s seal on the plans was made by Salim; seconded by Shanes. Ayes: Centanni, Shanes, Salim and Mulcahy No: Hitt Hitt voted ‘no’ because the plans did not have the required architect/engineer’s ‘seal’ ABR Discussion: Motion to approve subject to new materials matching the existing house, proper roof venting and matching soffets was made by Kline; seconded by Salim. Ayes: Centanni, Shanes, Hitt, Salim, Terlep, Kline and Mulcahy No: None #2 FENCE - Dr. Jon Fanaroff, Owner - 715 Beacon Hill Dr. - Great Lakes Fence Co. - Dan Makoroff, Representative Present: Dan Makoroff PZ/ABR Discussion: Joint motion to approve was made by Hitt; seconded by Salim. Ayes: Centanni, Shanes, Hitt, Salim, Terlep, Kline and Mulcahy No: None #3 ADDITION - Mr. Dae Kim, Owner - 28749 Jackson Rd. - BHC Siding Remodeling Co. Present: Albert Ham and Dae Kim - Albert Ham, Representative PZ Discussion: Motion to approve subject to creating a swale and removing a tree (as shown on plans) prior to beginning construction was made by Hitt; seconded by Centanni. Ayes: Centanni, Shanes, Hitt, Salim and Mulcahy No: None ABR Discussion: Motion to approve subject to all materials to match the existing house was made by Kline; seconded by Terlep. Ayes: Centanni, Shanes, Hitt, Salim, Terlep, Kline and Mulcahy No: None #4 LANDSCAPING - The Barkley Pet Hotel & Day Spa - 27349 Miles Rd. - Howard Perlmuter, Owner, Representative Present: Howard Perlmuter No Action Taken Discussion was had on fencing around the property and wild flowers around the retention pond. Members were recommended to go on a site visit. Howard Perlmuter to submit a revised plan. #5 BUILDING COMMISSIONER’S REPORT Lou has been gathering data for year-end reports. #6 ANY OTHER TOPIC FOR DISCUSSION Jonathan Shanes made a motion to adjourn into Executive Session for the discussion of prospective litigation; seconded by Brian Hitt. Ayes: Centanni, Shanes, Hitt, Salim, Terlep, Kline and Mulcahy No: None Meeting reconvened at 10:21 pm. Motion to approve the minutes of December 5, 2006 as amended was made by Centanni; seconded by Hitt. Ayes: Centanni, Shanes, Hitt, Salim, Terlep and Mulcahy No: None Abstain: Kline Corrections: #6 & 7 Add an “s” to ‘New Dwelling’ and add the word ‘both dwellings’ after the word ‘approve’. This will clarify two (2) separate dwellings were reviewed and approved. With there being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 10:23 pm. _______________________________ _______________________________ Mary Fisco, PZ Secretary Date